pssssst, hey you. free shipping & delivery on orders $99+ :)

Sleepy Hollow Shake

Sleepy Hollow Shake - Belle Isle Pumpkin Pie cocktail recipe

*makes 4 servings


  • 6-8 oz. Belle Isle Pumpkin Pie
  • 3 cups ice cream of your choice (we like vanilla or caramel)
  • 1½ cups milk or dairy substitute
  • caramel syrup + cinnamon sticks (garnish)


Chill 4 glasses in the freezer.

Combine Belle Isle, ice cream, and milk/dairy substitute in a blender. Add a few ice cubes, and blend until smooth.

Drizzle chilled glasses with caramel syrup, then divide the milkshake amongst the glasses. Garnish with a cinnamon stick or a sprinkle of ground cinnamon on top, then serve immediately.